Tackling Your Weaknesses in an Interview

By Kim Monaghan

 When asked about weaknesses during the interview, many believe that the best response is to talk about your “strengths” in disguise. While this approach may still work, it cannot be entered into lightly. In fact, unless it is delivered in a way that doesn’t appear as if it’s straight out of the “How to Succeed in Interviewing” guidebook, you’re authenticity may be in question. The best way to genuinely navigate this often perplexing question is by calmly offering an honest and value-laden response.

Be Honest. One approach is to respond with an honest weakness that won’t critically impact your success on the job. If you’re hoping to be promoted as a website developer but accounting isn’t your forte, this weakness won’t hurt you because it’s not a critical competency. The method of being honest is quite refreshing, as many applicants often resort to canned replies, such as “I’m a perfectionist” or “I’m a workaholic.” Recently, I had a client who stated “perfectionism” as their weakness during a mock interview. My first instinct was to cringe, but when he quickly followed it with an honest explanation, I was impressed. “I realize that’s something everyone says,” he went on to explain. “But in my case it’s true. I drive everyone crazy with this, but as an editor it’s my job to make sure all the “I’s” are dotted and “T’s” are crossed.” His response was honestly candid, and since his weakness served up a quality product, it worked beautifully. 

Offer Value. Everyone has weaknesses, but when you understand how these shortcomings drive you harder and further, you are well on your way to positively impacting a company’s bottom line. Begin with a short draft of your weakness then add the steps you’ve used to overcome (or manage) them. If you’re looking for a magic bullet to steer the interviewer off the track of what you don’t do well and on to what you do, you’ve just outlined it. Your proven plan for overcoming challenges is a value-laden competency. And when presented as an anecdote to a “weakness” you’ll provide the interviewer exactly what they need to hear.

Don’t Sweat. When you’re unprepared for this question it could wreck havoc on your ability to respond effectively to others that follow. Take time in advance to plot out your response and practice with someone who will give you honest feedback, but be careful that your response is not too rehearsed. If nerves do get the best of you during the interview, slow down take a deep breath and respond as if you were speaking to a friend.

Be Positive. Regardless of which approach you polish to deliver, end your reply on a positive spin. This begins with avoiding using the word weakness. Instead approach the response as a success story or a challenge you are methodically overcoming or have already conquered. Share your learning moments and how you utilize this powerful approach in work situations and how this behavior translates into impressive accomplishments. For example, if your weakness was public speaking and now you’re involved in toastmasters, share your journey of professional development and how your hard work has paid off.